Costco vs Sam's Club Food Storage Containers: Which is Better?

Are you looking to revamp your kitchen storage and streamline your food organization? Choosing the right food storage containers can make a significant difference in preserving freshness and maximizing space. This comparison dives into the offerings of two retail giants, Costco and Sam's Club, analyzing their respective food storage container sets to determine which provides the best value for your money. We'll examine price points, quantity, features, and overall quality to help you make an informed decision.Both Costco and Sam's Club offer various sets from reputable brands and their own Member's Mark lines. We'll be comparing specific sets, highlighting key differences in size, materials, and price. Our detailed analysis will weigh the pros and cons of each option, ultimately guiding you towards the best choice based on your individual needs and budget. Whether you need a large capacity set or a smaller, more focused solution, this comparison will equip you with the knowledge to make a smart purchase.

Pros And Cons

Costco Storage Containers
  • Airtight seal
  • Stackable
  • Suitable for pantry storage of cookies, cereal, pasta etc.
  • More expensive ($49.99) compared to the Sam's Club equivalent.
Member's Mark Storage Containers (Sam's Club)
  • Airtight seal
  • Stackable
  • Suitable for pantry storage of cookies, cereal, pasta etc.
  • Less expensive ($29.99) compared to the Costco equivalent.
Member's Mark Food Storage Containers (Sam's Club)
  • 24 pieces (12 containers, 12 lids)
  • Includes two large containers and more small containers than the Costco set

Read more: Cambro Food Transport Containers: A Caterer's Review of Two Models

Pyrex Glass Containers from Costco

Costco offers a 18-piece Pyrex glass container set, including nine containers and nine lids. These containers are advertised as BPA-free, airtight, microwave-safe, oven-safe, and dishwasher-safe. The set provides a convenient and versatile solution for storing various food items.

Close-up of the Pyrex container set
Close-up of the Pyrex container set

The price point for the Pyrex set was $24.99. While a practical option, the quantity of containers might be insufficient for larger households or those with significant food storage needs.

Member's Mark Containers from Sam's Club

Sam's Club's Member's Mark brand offers a 24-piece set. This includes 12 containers and 12 lids, providing more storage capacity compared to the Costco option. Similar to the Pyrex set, the Member's Mark containers boast BPA-free construction, airtight seals, and compatibility with microwaves, ovens, and dishwashers.

Member's Mark containers from Sam's Club
Member's Mark containers from Sam's Club

The Member's Mark set also costs $24.99, offering a larger quantity at the same price point as Costco's smaller Pyrex set. This makes it a superior value proposition for those needing more storage space.

The full Member's Mark set
The full Member's Mark set

Sam's Club's Additional Storage Container Set

Sam's Club also offers another storage container set (Members Mark), a set of 8 containers with lids. These are designed for pantry organization, keeping food items fresh, and are stackable for efficient space usage. The quality and functionality are comparable to other sets discussed.

Sam's Club's second container set
Sam's Club's second container set

The price of this Sam's Club set was $29.99, which was considerably cheaper than a similar 9-piece set at Costco ($49.99). Considering the price difference and slight reduction in quantity, this Sam's Club option presents excellent value.

Close-up shot of the containers
Close-up shot of the containers

Conclusion: Sam's Club Takes the Win

Based on the comparison, Sam's Club provides better value for money with its food storage container offerings. Both the larger 24-piece set and the smaller 8-piece set from Sam's Club offer competitive pricing compared to similar options at Costco. The larger quantity in the 24-piece set, coupled with the lower price of the 8-piece set, solidifies Sam's Club as the preferred choice.

While Costco's Pyrex brand has its merits, the superior value and quantity offered by Sam's Club make it the better option for those looking to stock up on food storage containers. However, it is worth noting that Costco might occasionally have sales, making their products more competitively priced.